Stakeholder Management Solutions for South African SMEs

Enhance SME Success through Effective Stakeholder Management

Discover strategies to boost your SME's success by mastering stakeholder management. Learn how effective communication and engagement with stakeholders can drive growth and sustainability for your small or medium-sized enterprise.

Successful businesses prioritise stakeholder management, recognising the importance of engaging with diverse stakeholders, including customers, employees, suppliers, and local communities. This approach involves understanding and addressing the varied interests and expectations of these stakeholders, fostering positive relationships through transparent communication.


Why Stakeholder Management is Crucial for SME Growth

Discover the pivotal role of stakeholder management in driving the success of small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs) with our comprehensive guide. From investors to employees, effective engagement with stakeholders is paramount for securing funding, enhancing brand reputation, and fostering long-term growth. By prioritizing strategic communication, transparency, and responsiveness, SMEs can navigate challenges, seize opportunities, and adapt to market demands with agility. Our guide equips SMEs with actionable insights and best practices, empowering them to cultivate strong stakeholder relationships and solidify their position in the competitive marketplace, ultimately propelling them towards sustainable growth and prosperity.

Effective SME Stakeholder Management Techniques


CONTEXT

Stakeholder management is the process of understanding and systematically identifying key stakeholders, analyzing their needs and expectations, and planning and carrying out various tasks to engage them. Entrepreneurs and business managers  coordinate interactions with stakeholders and assess the status and quality of their relationships with various stakeholders, including the community in which they operate. This skills programme provides a platform and tools for entrepreneurs and business managers to develop and implement stakeholder management plans.


Introduction to stakeholder management

Team Image

Written by: Malose Makgeta

MBA with 20+ years experience in SME development and funding. LinkedIn Profile


SME Stakeholder Management Lessons from Movies The Founder, War Dogs and Moneyball

CONTEXT

Stakeholder management is the process of understanding and systematically identifying key stakeholders, analyzing their needs and expectations, and planning and carrying out various tasks to engage them. Entrepreneurs and business managers  coordinate interactions with stakeholders and assess the status and quality of their relationships with various stakeholders, including the community in which they operate. This skills programme provides a platform and tools for entrepreneurs and business managers to develop and implement stakeholder management plans.

Key Lessons

Skills programme output

None



AEY's Dishonest Stakeholder Management: Trust Shattered and Reputations Tarnished

In the riveting saga of "War Dogs," the spotlight falls on AEY, a company entangled in the web of dishonest stakeholder management. Ephraim Diveroli and David Packouz, the brains behind AEY, ventured into the arms business with ambitious dreams, but their journey took a dark turn as they engaged in deceitful practices with stakeholders. For instance, AEY manipulated documents to secure government contracts, betraying the trust of both clients and regulators.

AEY's dishonest stakeholder management was primarily fueled by the allure of lucrative government contracts. In a cutthroat industry, where the stakes were high, Ephraim and David resorted to unethical practices to secure deals and maximize profits. The immediate gains from deceiving stakeholders blinded them to the long-term consequences of their actions.

The repercussions of AEY's dishonesty were far-reaching. Government agencies and clients who had placed trust in the company were left disillusioned. The impact extended beyond financial losses; reputations were tarnished, and AEY found itself entangled in legal battles. The dishonest stakeholder management, driven by short-sighted greed, ultimately eroded the foundation of trust upon which successful business relationships thrive.

As entrepreneurs, the cautionary tale of AEY serves as a stark reminder of the high cost of dishonest stakeholder management. Long-term success is built on trust, transparency, and ethical

What is Stakeholder Management: Strategies for Effective SME Stakeholder Management

Stakeholder management refers to the process of identifying, analysing, and engaging with individuals, groups, or organisations that have an interest or can be affected by a business, initiative, or organisation. Effective stakeholder management involves understanding the needs, expectations, and concerns of stakeholders and implementing strategies to address them. Most definitions of stakeholder management revolve around the concept of "managing your stakeholders (in order to get them to do what you want)". The emphasis is on developing a stakeholder management plan that maps stakeholders' levels of interest and influence and lists various levels of engagement for different groups.

A stakeholder is a person, group, or organisation whose interests are affected by the outcome of a business venture or business. As the name suggests, business stakeholders have an interest in the success of a business and can be internal or external to the organisation that is sponsoring the business.

The goal of stakeholder management is to foster positive relationships with stakeholders to gain their support, minimise conflicts, and maximise the chances of business success. It includes activities such as stakeholder identification, assessment of their influence and importance, development of communication plans, and engagement strategies. By actively managing stakeholders, organisations can anticipate and mitigate potential risks, align business objectives with stakeholder interests, and enhance decision-making processes. Stakeholder management helps create an environment of collaboration, trust, and transparency, enabling stakeholders to contribute to the success of the business or organisation.

Building and maintaining positive relationships with affected communities and other stakeholders is critical to the success of any business. Investing time in identifying and prioritising stakeholders, as well as assessing their interests, provides a solid foundation for your stakeholder engagement strategy. An in-depth understanding of your stakeholders, backed up by a strategic, clear, and prioritised engagement plan, will help you develop and maintain relationships with those affected, mitigate risks, align business goals, and eliminate delays. Stakeholder relationships can have a positive or negative impact on the life cycle of your business, so you'll need to identify your key stakeholders and develop a stakeholder management plan to meet their needs.

Business Stakeholders

In a business context, stakeholders refer to individuals or groups who have an interest or involvement in a company's operations, business, or outcomes. Here are some common types of business stakeholders:

Understanding and effectively managing the needs, expectations, and concerns of these business stakeholders is crucial for the long-term success and sustainability of a company.

Understanding Your Stakeholders

The key to a successful stakeholder engagement or public consultation programme is to begin with a thorough understanding of your stakeholders. And make sure to test and refine your understanding throughout the process. Salience model - investigate the power, urgency (need for immediate action), and legitimacy (appropriate stakeholders), as well as the interaction or groups of stakeholders that result.

First you need to be able to differentiate between internal and external stakeholders:

External or internal key stakeholders are both possible. An internal stakeholder is a professional who works directly for your company. Employees, business owners, investors, and board members are examples of internal stakeholders. External key stakeholders, on the other hand, are people who are affected by your business but do not work directly with you. Distributors, regulatory agencies, customers, and creditors are examples of external stakeholders.

Here are some criteria to consider when determining whether your stakeholder is internal or external:

Determine stakeholder expectations and compare them to the scope and expectations of the business or organisation for which the engagement program is being run. Is there a mismatch in expectations, and how will this be addressed?

Consider:

Stakeholder Engagement vs Stakeholder Management

They are both essential throughout the business lifecycle and allow for successful business completion.

What Is a Stakeholder Management Plan?

A stakeholder management plan is a written document that outlines how your team intends to manage key stakeholders' goals and expectations throughout the business lifecycle. A stakeholder management plan, is a business management document that identifies your business stakeholders and the strategies you'll use to communicate with them and meet their requirements.

A stakeholder management plan will typically include the following components.

Stakeholder Management Process

Stakeholder management is the process of organising, monitoring, and improving relationships with stakeholders. It entails systematically identifying stakeholders, analysing their needs and expectations, and planning and carrying out various tasks to engage them. A good stakeholder management process will allow you to coordinate your interactions and evaluate the status and quality of your relationships with various stakeholders.

McDonald's Stakeholder Management: Communication and Collaboration

In the world of burgers and fries, Ray Kroc orchestrated a stakeholder management symphony that would make Mozart jealous. Picture this: Ray, armed with a vision and a spatula, embarked on a journey to not only flip burgers but also flip the traditional notions of stakeholder relations. Brace yourself for a tale of handshake diplomacy, where every stakeholder, from franchisees to suppliers, played a crucial note in the McDonald's melody.

Ray's approach to stakeholder management was a dance of inclusivity. He realized that the success of McDonald's wasn't just about burgers; it was about building a community. Ray actively engaged with franchisees, listening to their concerns, and fostering an environment of collaboration. For instance, he instituted the Franchisee Advisory Council, giving franchisees a direct line to share insights and recommendations. This not only made them feel valued but also contributed to the continuous improvement of the McDonald's model.

The impact of Ray's stakeholder management strategy was nothing short of revolutionary. By fostering strong relationships with franchisees, Ray created a sense of ownership and commitment. This translated into consistent quality across all McDonald's outlets. Suppliers, too, were integral partners. Ray worked closely with them to ensure a streamlined supply chain, contributing to the reliability of the McDonald's brand. The Golden Arches became not just a symbol of fast food but a testament to the power of effective stakeholder management.

What can entrepreneurs glean from Ray's stakeholder management playbook? It's all about communication and collaboration. Ray understood that stakeholders weren't just business associates; they were partners in the McDonald's journey. Regular communication channels, be it through advisory councils or open forums, were the conduits of collaboration. So, next time you bite into a Big Mac, remember that behind those golden buns lies a story of stakeholder synergy orchestrated by the one and only Ray Kroc.

Why Stakeholder Management Important: Elevating SME Sustainability through Stakeholder Management

Stakeholder management plays a vital role in the success of business, initiatives, and organisations. Here are some reasons why stakeholder management is important:

Overall, stakeholder management is important for establishing positive relationships, managing risks, resolving conflicts, making informed decisions, enhancing reputation, and achieving long-term success for business and organisations.

Benefits of Stakeholder Management

Companies that recognise the value of actively developing and maintaining relationships with affected communities and other stakeholders benefit from improved risk management, increased stakeholder support, and improved outcomes on the ground.

Good stakeholder management also includes 'business intelligence'. Understanding stakeholder concerns and interests can lead to product or service ideas that address stakeholder needs while also allowing the company to cut costs and maximise value.

Effective stakeholder management is critical to the success of any business. Key stakeholders frequently have control over business resources such as business funds, employees, materials, or critical knowledge.

A documented stakeholder management plan of action ensures that your stakeholders' interests and expectations are understood, allowing you to manage them effectively. A plan allows you to explain to a business team how communication will take place, including who will be told what and when.

The process of developing a plan also allows you to analyze and better understand your stakeholders. This can help you anticipate their needs and address any concerns ahead of time.

Other Benefits:

Danger of failure to manage stakeholders

If key stakeholders are not engaged, or worse, are actively working against your business, your chances of success skyrocket.

Dealing with difficult stakeholders requires understanding what motivates them. Without a stakeholder management plan, you may not understand the underlying factors driving them, making it difficult to persuade them to support you.

Furthermore, if you do not assess and prioritise your stakeholders in your stakeholder management plan, you may waste a lot of time dealing with stakeholders who have little power while ignoring those who have the authority to derail your business.

Other risks:

Coaches, Scouts and Players: A's Stakeholder Management Unveiled

In the Moneyball saga, Billy Beane emerges not only as a baseball strategist but also as a master of stakeholder management. His orchestra? The Oakland Athletics, a team entangled in financial constraints and traditional baseball norms. Billy's stakeholder symphony was an intricate dance involving players, coaches, scouts, and the team's ownership. The dynamic nature of baseball required a delicate balance, and Billy, armed with data-driven insights, orchestrated a performance that would redefine the game.

One of the key stakeholders in Billy's playbook was, of course, the players. Traditionally, baseball decisions were often driven by subjective scouting reports. Billy, however, shifted the dynamic by focusing on data-backed player performance. He strategically managed player expectations and demonstrated how embracing an analytical approach could lead to individual and team success. For example, the recruitment of players like Scott Hatteberg, who transitioned from catcher to first base, showcased the impact of unconventional player management.

Billy's stakeholder management extended to coaches and scouts, a group deeply rooted in traditional baseball methods. As he introduced a data-centric approach, resistance was inevitable. However, through effective communication and showcasing tangible results, Billy managed to shift perspectives. Coaches and scouts adapted, realising that embracing analytics wasn't a threat but an opportunity to enhance their strategic input. An example would be the collaboration between Billy and Peter Brand, an economics graduate with a unique approach to player evaluation.

The A's ownership, a critical stakeholder, faced the challenge of embracing a revolutionary shift in baseball philosophy. Billy Beane's stakeholder management extended to demonstrating the financial benefits of the data-driven approach. The impact was felt not only on the field but also in the team's financial health. The A's, with their limited budget, began competing with big spenders, showcasing the transformative power of strategic stakeholder engagement.

The impact of Billy Beane's stakeholder management? A legacy of transformation in baseball. The A's became pioneers, challenging conventions and proving that a strategic approach to stakeholder engagement could reshape an entire industry. From players to ownership, each stakeholder played a vital role in the Moneyball revolution. The lesson? In any endeavor, navigating stakeholder relationships with strategic finesse can turn challenges into victories, creating a symphony of success.

How SMEs Manage Stakeholder: Essential Tips for Successful Stakeholder Management

Managing stakeholders effectively involves several key steps:

By following these steps and maintaining open lines of communication, organisations can effectively manage their stakeholders, build positive relationships, and increase the likelihood of business success.

Contrasting Stakeholder Management: McDonald's, the A's, and War Dogs Inc.

McDonald's: The Franchise Maestros

McDonald's, the global fast-food giant, is a masterclass in stakeholder management through franchising. Their approach involves a network of franchisees, suppliers, employees, and customers. The key is a delicate balance between standardisation and flexibility. McDonald's maintains control over core elements like branding and quality while allowing franchisees room for local adaptation. Stakeholder satisfaction is intertwined with the success of the franchisees, emphasising the collaborative nature of the McDonald's ecosystem.

Oakland Athletics (A's): The Moneyball Revolutionaries

The Oakland Athletics, under the guidance of Billy Beane, took a disruptive approach to stakeholder management in baseball. Players, coaches, and team ownership were stakeholders in this game-changing strategy. The A's embraced data-driven decision-making, challenging traditional scouting methods. Stakeholder engagement involved convincing players to adapt, coaches to evolve, and ownership to invest in a new philosophy. The impact was transformative, positioning the A's as pioneers challenging the status quo.

War Dogs Inc.: Ethical Quandaries and Entrepreneurial Hurdles

War Dogs Inc., in the arms-dealing business, navigated a complex web of stakeholders. Ephraim Diveroli and David Packouz, the entrepreneurs at the helm, managed relationships with suppliers, government agencies, and their own moral compass. Their stakeholder management approach was marked by ethical dilemmas. The impact of their decisions rippled through their venture, leading to legal challenges and strained relationships. War Dogs illustrates the high stakes and moral responsibilities tied to managing diverse stakeholders in a controversial industry.

Contrasts in Approach

McDonald's thrives on a collaborative franchise model, emphasising consistency and adaptability. The A's revolutionised baseball through a data-driven approach, challenging and transforming the conventional stakeholder dynamics. War Dogs Inc., in the arms industry, faced ethical dilemmas that showcased the complexities of managing stakeholders in a morally ambiguous space. Each organisation's approach reflects unique challenges, emphasising the importance of tailoring stakeholder management to the specific context and values of the industry.

Strategies for Smooth Stakeholder Management for SMEs

In essence, effective stakeholder management is a cornerstone for thriving businesses in today's dynamic landscape. The first key takeaway is the importance of recognising and prioritising diverse stakeholders, extending beyond customers and investors to include employees, suppliers, and communities. By understanding the unique needs and expectations of these stakeholders, businesses can tailor strategies to align with their interests, fostering positive relationships and building a foundation for sustainable success.

The second crucial aspect is a proactive approach to addressing stakeholder concerns. Regular communication, transparency, and the integration of stakeholder feedback into decision-making processes are vital components. This not only helps in building trust but also positions the business to navigate challenges more effectively. Moreover, considering the broader social and environmental impact of business activities is essential for maintaining a positive reputation and mitigating risks.

The overarching takeaway is that businesses integrating stakeholder management into their core strategy are better equipped to adapt to change, demonstrating resilience and long-term viability. This integrated approach not only ensures a positive business reputation but also contributes to a supportive ecosystem, fostering success in the ever-evolving marketplace. Ultimately, by recognising and proactively managing the interests of various stakeholders, businesses can position themselves as responsible, adaptable, and socially conscious entities.



Join the Conversation: Share Your Thoughts on This Article

  • No comments yet.

Add Your Comment Now!


Entrepreneur? Start-up or early-stages?
Entrepreneur? Ready to scale your business?
Investor or Funder? Looking for targeted SME investment opportunities aligned with your mandate?
Business Consultant? Wish to start or expand your business and management consulting business?
Enterprise Development Division and Institution? Are you looking for tailor-made SMEs for strategic development or procurement?